font size A A A

Swimming Question of the Week - June 3, 2009

Posted by Barbara Hummel on Jun 03, 2009 11:05AM (4,515 views)

Our question this week is purely speculative.  Michael Phelps has won gold in 8 Olympic swimming events (5 individual and 3 relay).  Do you think he could win gold in the other 8 events (all individual)?  This would include 100 & 200 breast; 100 & 200 back; 50, 100, 400 & 1500 free; and maybe even the 10K open-water swim for good measure in 2020.  What do you think?




Responses

Responded Jun 03, 2009 04:29PM

He is, indeed, a great swimmer, but I certainly do not think that he could win all 8 individual in one Olympics. He's big on Free and Fly, but I don't think he'd be able to pull off the Breaststroke. Perhaps if it was over the course of many Olympics, he could train to the necessary expertise for Breast. Maybe.

Responded Jun 03, 2009 05:35PM

He's dangerous in the backstrokes...

Responded Jun 03, 2009 06:30PM

no

Responded Jun 03, 2009 07:57PM

He is good at backstroke, and his breaststroke has improved a bit, but he is still not a breaststroker, and he is not good, to my knowledge at least, at distance events.

Responded Jun 03, 2009 07:59PM

No I don't think so...because of his breaststroke...but this is only an unproven opinion.

Responded Jun 03, 2009 08:04PM

I'm gonna have to say no simply because the 400 and 1500 are in there. I don't think he wants to swim that far anymore. :)

Responded Jun 03, 2009 09:26PM

Why he is not going to swim 400m? 1500m? cos his freestyle is good mmm maybe he getting bored to swim those long distances lol

Responded Jun 05, 2009 02:41PM

If only I could swim breaststroke like him...

Responded Jun 08, 2009 07:51PM

Nope...the concurence is comming up........

Responded Jun 09, 2009 04:51PM

50 Free - outside chance
100 Free - Yes
400 Free - Possible
1500 Free - Possible
100 Back - Yes
200 Back - Probably
100 Breast - Possible
200 Breast - Doubtful

No, 200 Breaststroke would be probably be his downfall but even if not, training for the 50/100 free AND the 400/1500 free is nearly impossible to do and be able to perform at the elite level. The differences between them in terms of technique and energy systems required are just too great.

Responded Jun 11, 2009 02:37AM

If Ian Thorpe can race and win the 100m and 800m free at Australian champs then i see no reason why Phelps couldn't compete across all distances and do this a US champs at least. If he can win them all at National level then I can't see anyone stopping him at international level. The man is a machine... His only weakness (can we call it that?) is his breaststroke but everyone would be in such awe of him he'd probably win anyway

Responded Jun 11, 2009 06:22PM

A little bit off topic:..uh..Rachael....sorry to say so, but how can you say such a thing?..."the man is a machine".....he surely is not a machine and can not do everything. I say this with all my respect for what he had accomplished already and wishing him every success. For sure his will is strong enough to ensure that we'll see a lot more from him during the upcoming years.
On topic: no one should attempt to win all events I think, no matter how his/her capabilities enable the person to do it....this is just not normal......a whole week full load (I think about the competition stress etc as well, no only the yardage and different technique requirement of the events)...doubtful.....that really would be a "machine" thing and not human at all.....and I know that human capability to adapt to increased, even extreme workload can do miracles....yet I'd not advise such a thing to anyone including Michael. (so my opinion is no)


User_go Please login or signup to leave a comment.


Underwater Tag Cloud

1650 Aaron Peirsol active drag active recoveryswimming Adam DeJong aerobic endurance age-group Amanda Beard anchoring android Android app ascending sendoffs backstroke balance Barry Murphy beach reading bilateral breathing birthday swim blueseventy Bobby Savulich Body Shape bodyline brain training breakout breaststroke breath control breathing Brendan Hansen broken swims buoy butterfly Carlos Almeida catch challenge set coaches coaching combat side stroke competition crossover turn Cullen Jones Cullen JonesKarlyn Pipes-Neilsen cycle rate Dave Denniston descend set distance per cycle distance training dive dolphin dolphin kick Dominik Meichtry DragSox Drills dryland DVD efficiency eggbeater kick Endless Pools Eric Shanteau Eric Vendt etiquette EVF fatigue feel Finis finish fins fist drill flip turn flip turns flutter kick Fran Crippen freestyle gallop stroke goals goswimtv.com hand entry hand exit head position heart rate hips hybrid IM inner strength iPhone app Jason Lezak Jeff Rouse Jessica Hardy Kaitlin Sandeno Kara Lynn Joyce Karlyn Pipes-Neilsen Kevin Clements kick kids learn-to-swim Lia Neal long axis strokes loping Margaret Hoelzer Martyn Forde masters Matt Patton medball Michael Phelps middle distance Misty Hyman mobile video monofin negative split neural Olympics one-hour swim open turns open water Over training pace pace clock paddles paralympics parents passive drag propulsion pull pulling pulse rates pushoffs pyramid questiontaper race specific training Rachel Stratton-Mills racing recovery relay starts resisted swimming rhythm Robert Margalis Roland Schoeman Roque Santos rotation Sara McLarty science Scott Tucker sculling SEALs shoulders sighting snorkel speed work sprint Staciana Stitts Starts stations Steve Haufler straight arm recovery streaming streamline stretch cord stretching stroke count stroke rate subscription support swim across america swim camps swim fun swim technique swim training swim video swimming Swimming Golf swimming music Swimsense swimsuit taper teaching Tempo Trainer tether timing training Triathlon tuck turn Turns underwater dolpin underwater pull Vasa water poloswimming water temp weights work to rest ratio Wu Peng

Who is GoSwim?

We are a group of swimmers who swim really fast, and like to help others learn how to reach their competitive potential in the area of professional swimming.

Want More GoSwim?

Subscribe to our RSS feed Subscribe to our RSS feed


 
built by devtwo