font size A A A

All Strokes - The Crutch

Posted by Glenn Mills on Apr 30, 2012 05:50PM (5,955 views)

This may be seen as more rant than drill, and some will like it, and some will not.  Either way, the pull buoy is what it is... a useful piece of swim equipment.

Why Do It:
Why use a pull buoy?  This wonderful piece of equipment, used by every elite swimmer since the inception, was invented by Fred Carbonaro in Birmingham, Michigan.  Its purpose is simple... to help swimmers achieve a better body position in the water, and isolate the arms for work on the pull.

How to Use It:
1. 
 We'll stick with the basics here... snug it up between your thighs.  Keep it high so the thickest part of your legs will get a good grip.
2.  Uh... that's it.  Ingenious huh?  A piece of equipment so simple in its design that almost no instructions are needed.

How to Use It Really Well (the Fine Points):
Here's where we get into its new name, "The Crutch."  The longer I'm in the sport, the more people I hear hating on the pull buoy.  I'd first like to know what Olympic swimmer hasn't used one.  That being said, obviously, Olympic swimmers aren't the ones people complain about.  It's masters swimmers and triathletes.  It's the "purists" who argue that if you use a pull buoy, you're doing the sport a disservice... you're cheating, and you're not learning to swim like THEY want you to learn to swim.  Does it make you feel better in the water?  Tough... don't use it.  Does it teach you what your body position will be if you're a wetsuit user in open water?  Tough... you need to learn how to swim without it, no matter how uncomfortable or how pointless training with horrible body position is.

As a swimmer, a swimming professional, and a pretty laid back person who just wants people to enjoy the sport, I say... lighten up on the pull buoy.  I use one just about every time I climb in the water.  I swim for enjoyment... I want to feel good.

Before we all start slamming the pull buoy, let's understand first what the goal of the swimmer is, what their ultimate race situation will be like, and if it's really our place to determine how someone else should spend their time in the water.  I, for one, am generally happy when people come to the pool.  If they choose to use a tool... cool.

PS - If you don't think I understand the importance of teaching proper swimming technique... look at the 1000+ videos we've created here at GoSwim.  This is more about our attitude as swim professionals to dictate to those who may be in the sport for something other than Olympic medals, and fastest swims.  Crazy, I know.

Pick up a nice pull buoy here.




Responses

Responded May 01, 2012 03:09PM

Very jerky play back, Glenn. Is that likely to be my end or at the host end?

Responded May 01, 2012 03:21PM

Your end. Sorry. May still be processing and working it's way around the world.

Responded May 01, 2012 03:28PM

Hmmm.... I'm generally anti-pull buoy, I must say. I like to have my kids cross their legs and swim without kicking. There are really two functions off taking legs out of the stroke: upper body skills focus and strengthening. While the pull buoy does make it easier to achieve proper overall body formation while isolating just the arms, since legs are like sharks and sink when not moving, I don't believe perfect body position is impossible without a buoy. With enough speed, the legs will lift, and the body will stay in position. As for strengthening, I think it's beyond argument that swimming with legs crossed is a tougher upper body workout than if one uses a buoy. That all being said, if you are looking to focus on the upper body skills at a slower and more deliberate pace, the buoy is probably still your best option.

Responded May 01, 2012 05:00PM

Sean, I agree, it all depends on where your focus is

Responded May 01, 2012 05:39PM

Glad people are disagreeing... and along that note... the text and video did point out, "triathletes and masters swimmers". When you're talking about "kids", you open up an entirely different discussion. There would probably be 10 different questions in the word "kids" itself. Even with that said... I think pull buoy are useful tools in some fashion for so many age groups. It's all about how you use them.

Responded May 01, 2012 08:06PM

I feel the rant. I have an exOlympian (1948), watching me coach... Complimenting my newer swimmers body lines and how quickly they are progressing, all the while letting me know that I cheat because they use equipment. Guess who's in Z2's now to build up her leg strength and keep up her cardio. We are now in agreement about the use of equipment for training! And she is now trying out her fly again since she's found some new freedom!
Love your rants!!!!!

Responded May 01, 2012 08:08PM

That's beautiful Tericom. All in moderation. :) 1948 Olympian... now that's a treasure.

Responded May 02, 2012 02:19PM

I've been using a Speedo pull buoy for focusing on freestyle pull technique and for continuing practice when my legs begin cramping. I've also been using Zoomer Z2's for free, fly, and back. Z2's help leg and core strengthening and getting feel of water and body position when going much faster in free, fly, and back. I do not use a kick board.

Responded May 03, 2012 05:38AM

I do enjoye the pull buoy for some things. I know I can't use it all the time, and I certainly don't! But for some things it really is nice. (I sure identify with the "masters swimmer & triathlete.")

Yes, it should be enjoyable to come to the pool. I do like working hard. And I do work hard. But it doesn't have to be hard every single moment!

Responded May 03, 2012 10:26AM

Even hard can be enjoyable if it is varied and properly explained, Sheila. Just, sometimes, coaches forget and pile on the meterage without due consideration to what the aim of the session is. Keep enjoying things!

Responded May 04, 2012 05:16AM

Oh, I do enjoy hard. Haha. That's part of my problem. Right?

Responded May 21, 2012 07:09AM

OK it is hard to freshman


User_go Please login or signup to leave a comment.


Underwater Tag Cloud

1650 Aaron Peirsol active drag active recoveryswimming Adam DeJong aerobic endurance age-group Amanda Beard anchoring android Android app ascending sendoffs backstroke balance Barry Murphy beach reading bilateral breathing birthday swim blueseventy Bobby Savulich Body Shape bodyline brain training breakout breaststroke breath control breathing Brendan Hansen broken swims buoy butterfly Carlos Almeida catch challenge set coaches coaching combat side stroke competition crossover turn Cullen Jones Cullen JonesKarlyn Pipes-Neilsen cycle rate Dave Denniston descend set distance per cycle distance training dive dolphin dolphin kick Dominik Meichtry DragSox Drills dryland DVD efficiency eggbeater kick Endless Pools Eric Shanteau Eric Vendt etiquette EVF fatigue feel Finis finish fins fist drill flip turn flip turns flutter kick Fran Crippen freestyle gallop stroke goals goswimtv.com hand entry hand exit head position heart rate hips hybrid IM inner strength iPhone app Jason Lezak Jeff Rouse Jessica Hardy Kaitlin Sandeno Kara Lynn Joyce Karlyn Pipes-Neilsen Kevin Clements kick kids learn-to-swim Lia Neal long axis strokes loping Margaret Hoelzer Martyn Forde masters Matt Patton medball Michael Phelps middle distance Misty Hyman mobile video monofin negative split neural Olympics one-hour swim open turns open water Over training pace pace clock paddles paralympics parents passive drag propulsion pull pulling pulse rates pushoffs pyramid questiontaper race specific training Rachel Stratton-Mills racing recovery relay starts resisted swimming rhythm Robert Margalis Roland Schoeman Roque Santos rotation Sara McLarty science Scott Tucker sculling SEALs shoulders sighting snorkel speed work sprint Staciana Stitts Starts stations Steve Haufler straight arm recovery streaming streamline stretch cord stretching stroke count stroke rate subscription support swim across america swim camps swim fun swim technique swim training swim video swimming Swimming Golf swimming music Swimsense swimsuit taper teaching Tempo Trainer tether timing training Triathlon tuck turn Turns underwater dolpin underwater pull Vasa water poloswimming water temp weights work to rest ratio Wu Peng

Who is GoSwim?

We are a group of swimmers who swim really fast, and like to help others learn how to reach their competitive potential in the area of professional swimming.

Want More GoSwim?

Subscribe to our RSS feed Subscribe to our RSS feed


 
built by devtwo